A question of fairness – how refereeing must evolve
March 2nd, 2025by Lisa Higgins
A football pitch can be for some a canvas for sporting artistry, free flowing creativity oozing of the page. Though, for some it can be the most lonely place in the world. No more so than match-day officials, cutting the most isolated of figures. Cajoled by players and berated by fans, with mistakes magnified in column inches and heightened sound bites.
In truth, referees may not be particularly well liked amongst fans but most football supporters agree they are a vital component of the game. In recent memory officials have been front and centre for vilification by fans, which has led to some unseemly behaviour.
One recalls former Swedish referee Anders Frisk resigning his position amongst European elite officials after receiving death threats towards his family, after he sent off Didier Drogba in a Champions League semi-final.
Such emotive, unjustified and unlawful threats are seen throughout the world. It will inevitably remain one of the darker elements of the sport, all stemming from perceived poor officiating. However, in truth, despite FIFA and the Football Association both maintaining standards will improve this firmly is not the case, this season certainly standards have slipped. With each poor or controversial decision, the trust is eroded even more.
Referees are arguably in a pressure situation from the very first whistle. Some, not all of that pressure comes from players haranguing and cajoling the referee. Despite this even former referees chief Keith Hackett, spoke out against his former colleagues over the Christmas period. Calling some performances as "bordering on the appalling".
Focusing in on Anthony Taylors dismissal of Swansea Wayne Routledge for his reaction to a hefty challenge by QPR is Karl Henry for special mention. Routledge later had his red card rescinded by the Independent Regulatory commission.
Recently, the ever outspoken Jose Mourinho lamented Martin Atkinson's performance in Chelsea's 1-1 draw against Burnley by recounting the specific minutes the referee failed in his duty of care. The Portuguese was well within his rights to critique Atkinson. Nemanja Matic's reaction to Ashley Barnes horror tackle by the letter of the law,warranted a red card.
However, inconsistency in the decision-making process struck again as Barnes escaped any retrospective action. Many would discount the Blues boss, however there was a sense that Chelsea had been very harshly treated. It's no wonder many are growing increasingly frustrated with the quality of match-day officials.
No sooner had the dust settled, at Old Trafford, match referee Roger East had sent off the wrong man. Sunderland's Wes Brown saw red in more ways than one after being wrongly dismissed. If ever proof was needed for video replays this was it.
Black Cats captain John O'Shea clearly fouled Radamel Falcao. The tricky Colombian turned O'Shea and the defender prevented him from
